Reviewers say ‘Tulsa King’ is lauded for its nostalgic mob drama and Sylvester Stallone’s standout performance. The show blends comedy and drama effectively, with Tulsa’s charm and engaging character dynamics noted. However, criticisms include unrealistic plotlines, clichéd tropes, and shallow character development. Some point to storyline inconsistencies and over-the-top scenes. Despite these flaws, many enjoy the light-hearted take on the mob genre and Stallone’s charisma.